| Date | Members’ Competition for MSR |
| 1960 | Archie MacPhail |
| 1961 | Ronald Lawrie |
| 1962 | Iain MacFadyen |
| 1963 | James Young |
| 1965 | Hector MacFadyen |
| 1966 | Iain MacFadyen |
| 1967 | Hector MacFadyen |
| 1968 | John MacFadyen |
| 1969 | Dugald Ferguson |
| 1970 | Hector MacFadyen |
| 1981 | Hugh MacInnes |
| 1982 | Kenneth MacDonald |
| 1983 | Barry Donaldson |
| 1984 | Alfred Morrison |
| 1985 | Roderick MacLeod |
| 1986 | Robert Wallace |
| 1989 | William McCallum |
| 1990 | Ronald McShannon |
| 1994 | John Patrick |
In 1981, 1982 and 1983 the winners recorded in the minutes do not agree with the dates on the trophy where the winners are listed for 1982, 1983 and 1983 November.
